4 Best Restaurants in Eureka, The North Coast

Brick & Fire Bistro

$$ Fodor's choice

Nearly every seat in this urbane bistro has a view of its most important feature—a wood-fired brick oven used to prepare everything from local Kumamoto oysters and creatively topped pizzas to wild-mushroom cobbler. Soups, several well-constructed salads, grilled meats, and seafood round out the menu.

Five Eleven

$$$ Fodor's choice

The chef at this colorfully lighted, contemporary, Old Town restaurant applies Western European techniques to mostly locally sourced ingredients in dishes that might include a wood-fired steak slathered in sauce au poivre, fish with saffron rice, or a mushroom-laden meatless cassoulet. Many patrons start with a classic or specialty cocktail or one of the clever mocktails.

511 2nd St., Eureka, California, 95501, USA
707-268–3852
Known For
  • small-plate and raw-bar starters
  • short but smart wine list
  • "Bananas Fosters" cake with spiced-rum caramel
Restaurants Details
Rate Includes: Closed Sun. and Mon. No lunch

Café Waterfront

$$

Amid Old Town's vibrant dining district, this rollicking spot in a former saloon and brothel turns out consistently fresh locally caught seafood—steamed clams, grilled snapper, oyster burgers, homemade chowder, and quite a bit more. Soups, salads, steaks, and burgers are on the menu, too, and breakfast, served only on weekends, is popular. After your meal, stroll a short way to Living the Dream Ice Cream for a gelato by the harbor.

Recommended Fodor's Video

Samoa Cookhouse

$$

Eat like a mill worker at this family-style former logging cafeteria's long, communal tables. You're here more for the blast from the past than the cuisine (think biscuits and gravy for breakfast, sandwiches and pot roast for lunch and dinner).