Fodor's Expert Review Posada La Hamaca

This building, which shares Mamacita's mangrove-lined canal, has spick-and-span guest rooms—as simple as they come—with louvered windows and calming color schemes. The inn sits on the edge of Dewey, putting you within walking distance of restaurants, shops, and grocery stores. The staff sends you off to the beach with towels and a little cooler filled with ice. If you plan to spend most of your time off-property and merely want a place to hang your hat, this is one of the best values on the island.